NED KELLY
The Widow's Son
BY
Stephen A. McCarthy
First published June 2007 by S. A. & R. D. McCarthy
Alligator Creek, Qld. Australia 4816
PO Box 1167, Aitkenvale, Queensland Australia 4814
© S. A. & R. D. McCarthy 2007
This book is copyright. Except for private study, research, criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright Act, no part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means without prior written permission. Enquiries should be made to the publisher.
Printed by Southwood Press, Marrickville, NSW Australia
National Library of Australia
Cataloguing-in-Publication Entry
McCarthy, Stephen A.
NED KELLY : the widow's son.
1st ed.
Bibliography.
ISBN 9780646475653 (pbk.).
1. Kelly, Ned, 1855-1880. 2. Bushrangers - Victoria- Biography. I. Title
364.155092
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I wish to thank my wife, son, and extended family for their patience over these many years listening to my favourite topic of conversation.
Thanks to my brother Peter for his many ideas, advice and sourcing of reference materials. He also contributed articles for this writing and helped focus my views. We tramped over the Bullock Creek area for nearly ten years either together or with our families.
My wife Renée has always encouraged me to continue my investigations when the effort, at times, seemed pointless. She has edited my original manuscript and transformed it from a poorly-contructed ramble to a story of which I am proud. Without her management, from organising the finished cover to ensuring the details of printing, photographs, etc. were accomplished, I could not have completed my goal.
Stephen A. McCarthy
20 May 2007
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PREFACE
CHAPTER 1 The Forest for the Trees
CHAPTER 2 The Bushranger
CHAPTER 3 1876
CHAPTER 4 1877
CHAPTER 5 1878
CHAPTER 7 Outlaws on the Run
CHAPTER 8 Jerilderie Letter
CHAPTER 9 The Bold Kelly Gang
CHAPTER 10 Waiting for a Train
CHAPTER 11 The Battle of Glenrowan
CHAPTER 12 The End of an Era
BIBLIOGRAPHY//RESOURCES
DOCUMENTS OF INTEREST
TABLE OF FIGURES
Figure A Approximate location of prospector's house. Line indicates Bullock Creek behind author.
Figure B Author's drawing of prospector's house as viewed from southeast.
Figure C Site of distilling hut. Bullock Creek in background behind Peter as viewed from the south.
Figure D Distilling hut site looking to the northeast. Line indicates Bullock Creek.
Figure E Author's drawing of distilling hut
Figure F Author's map of Bullock Creek area including location of police murders
Figure G Author's map of Kelly Camp at Bullock Creek.
Figure H Camera facing police camp in vicinity of site where Kennedy was shot.
Figure I Author's map of Kelly Country
Figure J Author's map of Stringybark Creek police camp
Figure K The police set up their camp on the east bank of Stringybark Creek.
The location is recognisable by being the only flat area between one
and two acres in size.
Figure L Author's map of Battle of Glenrowan
PREFACE
One of the major inspirations for my writing this book was a particular
murder trial in the USA. I happened to be there on holidays when a man's wife
went missing. I followed the investigation and resulting trial for about two years,
and was impressed with the way detectives assembled the most plausible scenario
from little bits of forensic evidence. According to detectives, whose job it is to solve
crimes, forensic evidence is far more accurate than eyewitness accounts. Oral history
may not be factual. The truth is determined by examining each piece of evidence in
detail.
Back home in Australia, a few years ago, I awoke about midnight with the
answer to a question that had been on my mind. Why were there contradictions about
Ned Kelly's hut at Bullock Creek, in Northeast Victoria? The answer was exciting. A
serious error had been made. Ned's famous 'fortified hut' was not a renovated prospector's
house, as popularly believed. The Kellys' 'fortified hut', for which I had been looking,
was located elsewhere.
My brother Peter and I had been investigating the information on the beginnings
of the Kelly Gang for about seven years. We concluded the location of their huts had a
significant bearing on the telling of the Kelly story.
This new information had consequences previously unexpected. For example,
we now believe their fortified hut was built entirely by the Kellys. In addition, the place
where Sergeant Kennedy's body is believed to have been found is wrong.
To determine the correct locations of the Kelly sites I have relied on original
information as recorded at the time. There were no surveyed maps of the area in 1878.
There are clues throughout the recorded documents as to when various events took
place. By estimating the time it took to build this other hut, the fences; ring-bark trees, etc.,
in addition to their travels and escapades, we think we've created a more plausible
and complete time line covering the activities of the Kellys.
Ever since I was a teenager, I have been fascinated with the story of Ned Kelly
and his Gang. After reading my first book about the bushrangers, I immediately borrowed
another book from the library to see if the first book was to be believed. From then on,
I have read just about every book and bits of information I could find on the subject and
often discussed them with Peter.
As I approached the age of fifty, I was still unconvinced that the many biographies
and historic accounts I had read were correct. There seemed to be so many discrepancies
and contradictions. As I understand it, Kelly researchers have been trying to write the
definitive biography for over a hundred years. The relatively same quotations, facts, and
photos appear in many books, but much more of the original material had been omitted.
I'll assume it had been left out as it contradicted the accepted storyline. In my opinion,
the resulting interpretations left much to be desired.
A Melbourne journalist's article has often been quoted from, in part, in various
books. Because the accepted location of the fortified hut is wrong, I feel, the journalist's
descriptions had been selectively used to suit the writer of the time. Our research has led
us to believe that he described what he saw without embellishment.
Throughout my life, I have visited many of the better-known historic Kelly sites.
In my mind, there has always been a problem in the logic of the accepted story. Over time,
it became apparent to me that the answer could lay where it all began, at the Kelly Camp
at Bullock Creek. My brother Peter lives in Victoria and has a background as a historian
specialising in gold mining. He agreed to join me. To begin determining the most plausible
history, we needed to locate the exact position of Ned's fortified hut.